Site Navigation
HomeAbout
Services
Testimonials
Contact
FAQ
Tastefully Indiana Bakery
"Indulge in Indiana’s Sweetest Comforts"
About Us
Tastefully Indiana Bakery, nestled in Kokomo, IN, serves up a delightful array of sweet creations since 2020. Our cake shop is a haven for those with a sweet tooth, offering a delectable selection of cookies, cupcakes, pies, cheesecakes, and tempting weekly specials. Proudly serving the greater surrounding area, we craft each treat with care, infusing every bite with the warmth and flavors of Indiana. Come taste the essence of Tastefully Indiana Bakery – where every bite is a celebration!
Areas Served
Carroll County, IN | Howard County, IN | Boone County, IN | Hamilton County, IN | Tipton County, IN | Cass County, IN | Miami County, IN | Carmel, IN
What We Offer
Our Specialties include:
- On-the-Go with Take-n-Bake Meals
- Hiring Cake Decorator & Baker
- Pies
- Pot Pies
Our Services include:
- Bakery: Enjoy fresh-baked goodness made daily, from classic breads and pastries to custom cakes and sweet treats. Our bakery focuses on quality ingredients, homemade flavor, and beautiful presentation—perfect for every occasion.
- Holiday Specials: Celebrate the season with our limited-time holiday favorites, featuring festive flavors, themed desserts, and beautifully crafted treats. Whether you're hosting a gathering or gifting something sweet, our holiday specials make every moment extra memorable.
- Weekly Specials: Discover something new each week with our rotating selection of baked goods, discounts, and featured flavors. Our weekly specials highlight customer favorites and seasonal creations—always fresh, always delicious.
Our Products include:
- Cookies
- Cupcakes
- Bunt Cakes
- Crème Horns
- Cheesecakes
- Macarons
Testimonials
On 5/6/2026
Marie Peterson
had this to say:
We stopped for lunch at Tastefully Indiana in Kokomo on the way to Tulip Time in Holland, MI. The owner of this small business makes delicious pies (savory and sweet), cakes (with quite the variety of fillings), cheesecake, and cookies. It’s obvious she enjoys her job and serving her customers! The shepherd’s pie was well-seasoned with a great texture- both a flaky crust and creamy potatoes. The coconut cream cheesecake was smooth and flavorful. The sweets/baking tree and the light-fixture added unique touches to her cheery little bakery! We highly recommend this place— thank you!!
!
On 1/25/2026
Shelly Israel
had this to say:
My hubby is hooked on their cookies. They have pot pie and other foods also.
On 11/16/2024
Tammy Cody
had this to say:
Yummy cookies and pies.
On 9/18/2024
Stacy Russell
had this to say:
We hired Tastefully Indiana to cater for a work party and the food was delicious! I would recommend Amy and her team for your catering needs.
On 8/18/2024
Greg Holmes
had this to say:
Amazing experience and their staff is amazing thanks guys
Contact Us
Tastefully Indiana Bakery
3700 S Lafountain St Kokomo, IN 46902
Phone: (765) 480-9727
Email: tastefullyindiana
Payment Types Accepted
American Express, Debit Cards, Discover, MasterCard, Visa
Our Hours
Tuesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Wednesday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Thursday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Friday: 10:00 AM - 6:00 PM
Saturday: 10:00 AM - 3:00 PM
FAQ
Legal
Terms of UsePrivacy Policy